Published Photo Intelligence Lab by Narkis

How the AI-or-real photo blind test works

Where every photo comes from, how each one is prepared and dealt, which answers count, and what the numbers can and cannot tell you.

What the test is

A public blind test: 12 photos of people, one at a time, and one question for each: AI or real photo? Half are real photos of real people, mostly everyday shots; half are AI photos of other people. You see the answer after each photo and your score at the end. Every counted answer feeds the live results.

Where the photos come from

No competitor or stock photos are used. Nobody is pictured without their consent or their own free licence. The set holds 66 photos: 36 photos made by AI and 30 photos of real people. List updated .

AI side: 36 photos

Our founder, made with Narkis · 8 photos

Picked from Adam's own Narkis generations (his trained Narkis model, the same pipeline customers use). Picked for looking most like ordinary photos; not retouched.

Consent: Adam, the person pictured, asked for his photos to be used in this public test.

People who don't exist · 28 photos

Generated with the open Z-Image Turbo model on our own GPU from prompts in the style Narkis customers use (phone photo, everyday places). Picked for realism; not retouched.

Consent: Not needed: these people are not real. Any likeness to a real person is accidental.

Real side: 30 photos

AuthorLicenceSource
ScottFerreiraCC BY 4.0commons.wikimedia.org
Ruby D-BrownCC BY-SA 4.0commons.wikimedia.org
TrougnoufCC BY-SA 4.0commons.wikimedia.org
Ainur physicistCC BY 4.0commons.wikimedia.org
Ravinak11714CC BY-SA 4.0commons.wikimedia.org
JenOttawaCC BY-SA 4.0commons.wikimedia.org
Jonpotter01CC BY-SA 4.0commons.wikimedia.org
MJBeckerCC BY-SA 4.0commons.wikimedia.org
Dr Mohamad AlissaCC BY-SA 4.0commons.wikimedia.org
Nina EgerCC BY-SA 4.0commons.wikimedia.org
SergioOrenCC BY 4.0commons.wikimedia.org
Angelabhutia16CC BY-SA 4.0commons.wikimedia.org
ArmineaghayanCC BY-SA 4.0commons.wikimedia.org
Erika MayoralCC BY-SA 4.0commons.wikimedia.org
Slobadava DaryaCC BY-SA 4.0commons.wikimedia.org
Hannah CloverCC BY-SA 4.0commons.wikimedia.org
Audebeau celineCC BY-SA 4.0commons.wikimedia.org
Kim NoethCC BY-SA 4.0commons.wikimedia.org
Alex NemanCC BY-SA 4.0commons.wikimedia.org
Rainer zimmermannCC BY-SA 4.0commons.wikimedia.org
LucyinCC BY-SA 4.0commons.wikimedia.org
Nella.hohlovaCC BY-SA 4.0commons.wikimedia.org
Moe EpsilonCC BY-SA 4.0commons.wikimedia.org
Jean François MathieuCC BY-SA 4.0commons.wikimedia.org
Sujita dahalCC BY-SA 4.0commons.wikimedia.org
Ajaintt123456CC BY-SA 4.0commons.wikimedia.org
RichifieldCC BY-SA 4.0commons.wikimedia.org
Scharfheld RegenbogenCC BY-SA 4.0commons.wikimedia.org
NkansahrexfordCC BY-SA 4.0commons.wikimedia.org
Mayakp.wikiCC BY-SA 4.0commons.wikimedia.org

Photos aren't shown on this page, and the credits are not in play order, so the list gives no answer away.

The real photos are self-portraits their authors published on Wikimedia Commons. We crop and resize them; each cropped copy keeps its author's licence (CC BY or CC BY-SA, linked above).

How every photo is prepared

Nothing in the file gives the answer. Every photo, AI or real, goes through the same steps:

  • The same 4:5 portrait crop.
  • The same size, 1200 × 1500 pixels, with the same resampling.
  • All metadata stripped, including EXIF, camera and software tags and C2PA content credentials, then re-encoded the same way.
  • Served under an opaque, random URL with no file name or extension, signed for 15 minutes.

How a round is dealt

Each round deals 12 photos: 6 AI and 6 real, drawn at random from the set and shown in random order. Your browser receives an id for each photo, nothing more; the photo itself is fetched right before it appears. Whether a photo was AI or real is revealed only after you answer it.

What counts

  • Answers given less than 300 ms after the photo was served are excluded as likely bots. Our server times this, not your browser.
  • Each photo can be answered once per round; a repeat doesn't change the first answer.
  • Answers are anonymous: no account, no name, no email. No IP address is stored, only a hash of the browser's user agent and the country reported by our CDN.
  • Age band, gender and country are optional and self-reported.
  • Rounds played by the team on draft photo sets are left out.

How the live numbers are computed

The headline is the share of counted answers that called the photo right, with a 95% Wilson score interval. It is shown from 30 counted answers on. A coin flip would score 50%. The live interval treats answers as independent; answers from one player are not, so the published study will cluster by player (a player-clustered bootstrap) and its interval will be somewhat wider.

What we will and won't claim

  • The photo set is small, so a few unusually easy or hard photos move the numbers. Per-photo results are published without labels so they don't spoil the test.
  • Players are self-selected visitors, not a representative panel.
  • Friends of the team may recognise some faces.
  • The AI side includes photos of our founder made with Narkis, which sells AI photos. That is a conflict of interest, and the reason this method and the uncertainty are public.
  • The real side is mostly self-portraits that people published under free licences, not professional photos.
  • The result describes these photos and these players. It is not a general claim about all AI photos or all people.

How to cite

How to cite (APA)

Narkis. (2026, November 17). AI or real photo? The blind test [Data set]. Photo Intelligence Lab by Narkis. https://narkis.ai/research/blind-test/ai-or-real/results

Embed the live test

<iframe src="https://narkis.ai/research/blind-test/embed" title="Can you tell AI from a real photo? Blind test by the Photo Intelligence Lab by Narkis" width="100%" height="260" style="border:0;max-width:560px" loading="lazy"></iframe> <p><a href="https://narkis.ai/research/blind-test">AI or real photo? Blind test</a> by the Photo Intelligence Lab by Narkis</p>

A small card with the live score and a button into the test. Preview the embed.

Aggregated results are free to reuse under CC BY 4.0 with credit to the Photo Intelligence Lab by Narkis.

Withdrawal

Anyone pictured in the test can ask for their photo to be removed: write to [email protected]. A withdrawn photo is taken out of the set, including from rounds already in progress.

Photo Intelligence Lab by Narkis. Blind test · All research